Mason llp steam legit. ” Steig Olson of Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP, a lawyer for one of the groups of plaintiffs, told Law360: “We disagree with Valve’s arguments. Mason llp steam legit

 
” Steig Olson of Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP, a lawyer for one of the groups of plaintiffs, told Law360: “We disagree with Valve’s argumentsMason llp steam legit  Valve is one of the world’s largest online game retailers and operates the Steam game distribution platform

is in court for allegedly breaching of the Sherman Antitrust Act. Mason LLP, a firm affected by the DC Health Link ("DCHL") data breach, was first to file a class action lawsuit against DCHL on March 14, 2023. Search reviews. 2:21-cv-00563, and it is in. Valve Corporation, the gaming giant behind the popular gaming platform Steam, has recently found itself in hot water. C. A D. Valve Corporation, the gaming giant behind the popular gaming platform Steam, has recently found itself in hot water. Mason LLP was the first to file a Class Action Lawsuit against Regal Medical Group, Inc. Valve Corp. Wilson Mason LLP | 1,131 followers on LinkedIn. #footer_privacy_policy | #. must face antitrust litigation over claims that “most favored nation” policies for its Steam. Gary M. Valve. We consider ourselves one of the. The letter advised the viewer, a Raleigh woman, that an $8. 3 January 2017. Mason LLP is now representing thousands of Steam customers through individual arbitration. Courses 340 View detail Preview siteThe Mason LLP Steam Lawsuit is a high-profile case that has brought attention to the issue of corporate responsibility. Valid. The steam system, often an overlooked and neglected utility, holds the key to improved equipment reliability, improved process efficiency, reduced energy costs, reduced emissions, and ultimately increased profitability. 20015-2052. They are usually built on the premise of the lawyer receiving a payment (e. Each consumer may have suffered damages as high as 60% of the purchase price of all games purchased during the last four years. Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. Suite 640 Washington, D. Decades of experience. Taylor represents public and private companies, venture funds, and private equity investors in a range of complex transactions and corporate matters, including mergers and acquisitions, venture financings, capital markets offerings, and shareholder. Get to know your team by clicking View All. looks like a Scam yet no matter how many times it is reported FB fact checker are so tied up hunting down anything Covid or Hunter that they can not be bothered with it. Please click on the country. com is legit or scam. referred to in this agreement as "Attorneys" and Client, asdf asdf (Note: this is my fake name), referred to in this agreement as “Client. They are trying to bring a class action lawsuit against Valve for being a "monopoly. Next. W. Date. right now is the summer sale, it ends on the 5th. Have not really seen it where they are charging more than Amazon or gamestop Walmart etc. A Steam phishing scam involves sending you to a fake Steam page where you'll be persuaded to give your login details to a scammer. Mason Jars. A subreddit for members of the Steam Community and fans of steam. A U. Check your eligibility now. Phishing scams are by far the most common Steam scam you'll encounter. 11mo. Mass arbitration involves groups of workers or consumers initiating arbitration claims against the same company. Find a Location. One such case has emerged with the Mason LLP steam lawsuit, a class action filed against Mason LLP, a law firm accused of marketing and selling the. We equip our clients with expert support that minimizes risk while finding. , (“Convergent” or “Defendant”). Interim Co-Lead Counsel will have sole authority over all matters concerning the prosecution of the class action against JDC on behalf of the Plaintiffs and the proposed class. The firm is also frequently involved in class action lawsuits. The Firm was formed in 2019 to serve as special litigation counsel to Connecticut-based alternative asset manager Black Diamond Capital Management, L. In-game purchases: A Steam refund is available on purchases made in games from parent company Valve for up to 48 hours after purchase, as long as the games hasn't been played, modified, or transferred. Wilson Mason LLP is a multidisciplinary practice with expertise in the fields of architecture, interior design, master planning, 3D Modeling and Principal Designer duties. Scale: A+ to F. 20015-2052. 4 days ago Web Jul 25, 2023 · ROCKFORD, Ill. Sunbeam Breadmaker Parts. Only good for reading the comments on dark souls. May 10 ·. Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. (202) 640-1161. If you had a Steam account between 2018-2022, you may be entitled to compensation. Report an investment scam. Check your eligibility now. This lawsuit stems out of the unauthorized access and exfiltration of Personally Identifiable Information of thousands of individuals who receive insurance benefits through this carrier. From Humblebundle of all places, which is strangely a place I buy Steam steam games from legally on occasion. Mar. If we do, our fee is 40% of the recovery. If you are a Steam user in the U. How much refund can I get?Gamers on Steam could get a portion of their money back. In the class action lawsuit, lawyers tried to bring federal antitrust claims on behalf of PC-game developers and Steam users. Steam is by far the most popular. If you can look past the goatee, you've got Ariella. FaceBook Scam "steam antitrust lawsuit" FaceBook scam trying to get your info. $1150 for another/hr. Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. 28, 2022 – Gary E. Having a monopoly in itself isn't illegal. Today we break down why the suit is back on, and what this means for Steam. Duke Smythe Associates. Parker & Mckenzie, Inc. A law firm called Mason LLP is now representing thousands of Steam customers who live in the US and are 18 or older. - Representing employees and consumers in complex class action suits. Bytedance Tech. (“Bosley”), a hair-restoration clinic. While steam is a *legit* company, you won't be able to take advantage of obvious sale-listing errors over 100%. Suppose that, out of the blue, a Steam user tells you they’ve accidentally reported you for something you didn’t do, like making an illegal purchase, and that your Steam account is going to be suspended. As a safety feature, the lid will not open unless all pressure is. Zaiger LLC is a unique law firm providing an alternative model of first-tier business litigation aimed at aligning incentives with our clients to create superior returns. Specifically, Steam's commissions and use of its monopolistic powers have made games cost more for them. Drawing on our extensive history of design and management, we work closely with our clients and building users to produce exceptional. Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. 80. Phone number (905) 276-9111. For more information, visit Whitfield Bryson & Mason online at or call 1-855-926-2889. BBB File Opened: 9/16/2020. Report a scam or fraud, or browse and view scams reported by others. Valve is facing…Unleash the power of Kratos and take on the adventure of a lifetime in God of War. Judge advances case after previously ruling in Valve’s favor. It’s all a lie told to part you from your cash. Robertson & Associates, LLPScam emails can include warnings about expired antivirus settings or an infection on your computer. Time To Credit 2 Days. Location of This Business. Class actions are not handled through individual arbitration for one thing and for another there's zero shot any judge anywhere actually ruled Steam as being a monopoly because they have objectively always had competition from at least brick and mortar stores, they still do to this day, and. , Suite 900. C. You can build anything from a small structure to a large city, or even multiple towns in a single scene. Mason LLP filed a Class Action Lawsuit against OakBend Medical Center (“OakBend”) on November 17, 2022. 1. Rowenta Steampod Attachments. Valve Corp. Larry Martin, Justice of the New York Supreme Court, denied Defendant Assistcare Home Health Service’s motion to compel…legit players only, no glitches cheats modded items OR TRAINERS. Illinois Steam users can submit a claim through the firm’s settlement website. Steam is by far the most popular. It's pretty clear as this is for a NO question ask refund. You made too many requests in 1 hour, we show captcha now:Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. com Tel: (202) 429-2290. Drawing on our extensive history of design and management, we work closely with our clients and building users to produce exceptional. Los Gatos, CA 95032. 2. " for their paralegals and clerks. Office of Personnel Management to recoup up to $10,000 apiece. Sam Bankman-Fried Convicted of Fraud in. ; They can use the gift card to. it’s full steam. Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. Learn how your comment data is processed. That order was never delivered. From rumors to speculations, the internet is abuzz with discussions about its legitimacy. Wilson Mason LLP | 1,116 followers on LinkedIn. You can search the lawsuit. When one came to a CBS 17 viewer, they asked consumer investigator Steve Sbraccia to check it out. If you had a Steam account between 2018-2022, you may be entitled to compensation. Share Add a Comment. With a team of seasoned attorneys and a track record of successful cases, they have earned a reputation as one of the foremost law firms in the industry. Average of 12 Customer Reviews. I think it was S6. 3 million people being exfiltrated. Do you have a Steam account? You may be entitled to get up to a 60% refund. OakBend is a nonprofit hospital located in Texas that has been providing healthcare services to the Greater Houston Area since 1947. Sep 21, 2023. Emily Cousins. More people involved, the bigger the settlement, the bigger the payout for the firm. Common. It is not meant to convey the Firm’s legal position on behalf of any client, nor is it intended to convey specific legal advice. The lawyers will not file your. is mason llp steam legit Mason LLP Steam is a legitimate business that has been. 21 Nov, 2022 -SIGN-UP IS CLOSED FOR THIS CASE- What is the case about? Mason LLP represents tens of thousands of gamers with claims against Valve, the owner of Steam. STEAM GAMERS: You could get REFUNDED up to 60% of your purchases from the last FOUR years. They are based on the quality of the customer service in its Legal Services field, public feedback, complaints on social media, the. W. 1. I did it all on mobile using the Brave browser. eBay Scams Click here to access a full list of eBay scams, from eBay buyer tricks to car sales and warranties. When one came to a CBS 17. You can reach out to the law firm and see if your eligible to join the class action. Log In. 408-356-3000. #7Mason LLP’s Gary Mason has been appointed as Interim Co-Lead Counsel on JDC Healthcare Management LLC litigation. RALEIGH, N. It employs over 450 physicians along with 1,200 other staff members. Steam Refund Lawsuit: Is Mason LLP Legit? August 20, 2023 August 18, 2023 by Chad Garcia DDS. Suite 640 Washington, D. With exceptional customer service and a vibrant community, Mason LLP Steam checks all the boxes for a legit gaming experience. (“Bosley”), a hair-restoration clinic. Lynn Austin vs. Personal injury refers to any incident where an individual suffers fatal, physical and/or emotional injuries. FFL2and3rocks Nov 5, 2022 @ 11:02pm. " Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. 2 min read. Coughenour let part of the case move forward in the U. Read More: #databreach. ago. 3 min read. Steam is the most legit of them all. Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. Drawing on our extensive history of design and management, we work closely with our clients and building users to produce exceptional. This mean that the suits may continue to the next stage, discovery. Mason of Mason LLP and Anne French-Hodson of Sharp Law and to. Wilson Mason LLP is a multidisciplinary practice with expertise in the fields of architecture, interior design, master planning, 3D Modeling and Principal Designer duties. ago possiblynotracist Any thoughts on this steamclaims. im happy with steam and ye its legit!@ :) have a nice day. Valencia, CA 91355-0933. , No. It usually includes someone not sticking to their promise, and not sending the payment or skin. When arbitration clauses bar you from joining together with other employees or consumers to bring a class-action lawsuit, mass arbitration can be a way to still gain an advantage and give you negotiating power. You won't win either. A law firm called Mason LLP has filed a lawsuit against Valve, claiming that the company has been misleading customers with. They argue that Valve illegally charges higher prices to its customers. after the "reporting for illegal purchases" line I google "reporting for illegal purchases. . Valve was sued in a class action lawsuit by developers for their anticompetitive restraints on pricing. Washington, DC. Mason LLP's ads are for people who want to file arbitration claims against Valve, not lawsuits. district judge has decided that an antitrust lawsuit against Valve over how it operates and uses the Steam platform can move forward. Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. Wilson Mason LLP | 1,112 followers on LinkedIn. But the judge ruled that users can’t be part of that lawsuit. - Please note that we are not affiliated with Steam, Valve Corp, or any other company or service in any way. Mason Jars with Handles. Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. The Steam Autumn Sale is on now — find great deals on thousands of games!Mason, LLP claims that people may be eligible to recover as much as 60% of the purchase price of all the games they’ve purchased on Steam over the last four years. Use Steam for game purchases? Mason LLP is currently representing hundreds of gamers with claims against Valve, the owner of Steam. Get Directions. Tldr, it's no secret that there are images from Getty Images in the training data. It is not a bill requesting payment, which you would immediately delete. The firm responded to Plaintiff’s concerns and in turn filed a complaint in the District Court for the. The name of the game developer case is Wolfire Games, LLC, et al. Reply replyFacebook has a steam scam going on, don't be fooled and log into your account through their links. Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. Mason LLP represents thousands of Steam gamers and is preparing their claims for arbitration. In this scam lawyers will be duped into wiring real funds from their trust accounts after. Even for a not so interesting one if it has a big-time studio behind, it will be $60. Gamers who purchased on Steam could get money back on their past purchases. Contact Us. A Court in Potter County, Texas appointed Mason LLP’s Gary Mason as Co-Lead Counsel to lead the Consolidated Class Action against FMC Services in a data breach lawsuit. Last November, Western District of Washington Judge John Coughenour sided with Valve in dismissing a Steam antitrust lawsuit that. Mason Law Firm is a full service law firm. Tweets. Complaint History & Business Rating for Mason LLP 950 Winter Street, Suite 1300, Waltham, Massachusetts, 2451, United States. Steam Lawsuit Mason LLP is a legal powerhouse renowned for its prowess in handling a wide array of legal matters. Don't wait, time is running out!. I am gauging interest for a class action lawsuit for fraud against Steam. 28494 Westinghouse Pl #202. Mason LLP is a civil litigation firm representing plaintiffs who have been injured or harmed by corporate misconduct. Mason LLP Steam is a legitimate business that has been providing quality steam cleaning services to commercial and residential customers for several years. , Mar. Judge Gutierrez of the US District Court for the Central District of California gave his final approval in a class action settlement against Bosley Inc. And other PC game platforms exist, they just aren't any good, so that's why publishers keep coming back to Steam. In 2022 alone, we estimate BBB Scam Tracker helped consumers avoid losing $21 million to scammers. com. Anyone can make a mistake and buy the wrong game in a hurry or spend a lot of money on a game that cannot. Sunbeam Mixer Parts. Achieve your dreams with lets not Achievement Worldbox! Our online platform helps you turn your ideas into action through an organized approach to goal setting, tracking progress, and taking meaningful steps forward. Further Reading. com. Wilson Mason LLP | 1,113 followers on LinkedIn. In a January 2019 tweet, Sweeney said Steam "has veto power over prices". According to reports, the class action lawsuit stemmed from the fact that Valve Corporation has. - Specializing in wage and hour. , a software provider for insurance companies, has agreed to pay $11 million to settle a class action alleging the companies failed to protect the…The Phone Call (s) About a month ago I was relaxing on my back porch with a cup of coffee, watching my French bulldog puppy romp around the yard when my cell phone rang. This is their whole argument that this practice violates free market economy principles. Judge Farrish was, until December 31, 2019, Attorney Mueller's law partner. All trademarks are property of their respective owners in the US and other countries. Illinois Steam users can submit a claim through the firm’s settlement website. Shot Glasses. Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. Help the Better Business Bureau investigate scams and warn others. Email I received from Valve today. Gamers with Steam accounts could get money back. So, dear fellow gamer, fear not the whispers of doubt when it comes to Mason LLP Steam. Mason LLP Law Firm Headshots by Branding Photographer Karrie Porter Bond Previous. Have not really seen it where they are charging more than Amazon or gamestop Walmart etc. This scam originates via fax. The Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia has today dismissed an appeal by Valve Corporation (Valve) against a ruling that it engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct and made false or misleading representations about consumer guarantees. Related Professionals: Pamela Coyle Brecht , Michael A. Case Intake Specialist. Search our database to see if a similar scam has been reported. Mason LLP is a national law firm. Is this your business? PeopleClaim Reliability Rating. From the limited research I can find, they want you to let them do arbitration for you and have crazy fees that will undoubtedly consume any money they could recover. 975. Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. is in court for allegedly breaching of the Sherman Antitrust Act. High-powered attorney who become a top federal regulator ‘preyed on’ students and colleagues over nearly 2 decades, women allege. Close This blog is made available by Foley & Lardner LLP (“Foley” or “the Firm”) for informational purposes only. I did it all on mobile using the Brave browser. com is legit or scam. Mason Jar Hanging Sets. Gamers on Steam could get a portion of their money back. Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. You won't have to pay upfront fees as the law firm takes a percentage of what you win or. I got a refund for a faulty game, way back during the "no, we don't give refunds at all. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. each time they step in, the account gets a cooldown that keeps getting longer till you can no longer make changes. Just build as much as your heart desires. #1. Sep 2016 - Mar 20203 years 7 months. Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. com having an authoritative rank of 75. There is no dead Uncle Fred, no rich deceased Reese. Valve Corporation is facing an antitrust class action lawsuit after it was accused of allegedly taking advantage of its market dominance to weed out potential competition. 2:21-cv-00563, and it is in. If you've been impacted by Valve's anti-competitive practices, you may be entitled to a refund. Bradley-Mason LLP Construction Harrogate, North Yorkshire 445 followers A specialist Chartered Building Surveyors for Commercial Properties, operating in all major cities across the countryWilson Mason LLP | 1,114 من المتابعين على LinkedIn. Steam Antitrust Lawsuit by Mason LLP. WeMason Lietz & Klinger continues to ensure that victims of data breaches are compensated for their losses. Drawing on our extensive history of design and management, we work closely with our clients and building users to produce exceptional. A: Yes, the lawsuit is considered a legitimate legal action due to its strong evidence and clear violations of multiple laws. We do not shy away from hard work or a challenge. In a nutshell, it appears partially legitimate, but the way Mason LLP is going about it is very sketchy and highly likely to mislead people into thinking they have a settlement in hand. Log In. Richmond, VA 23219. com Tel: (202) 429-2290. PDH Transfers LLC. Vice PresidentA court ruled that customers can sue Valve. Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. Mason LLP in Moses Lake, WA Expand search. gamers and polishing gabe's dick, name a more iconic duo. 05/26/2022. csanders@masonllp. Gifts: If a gift hasn't been redeemed, it can be refunded within 14 days. (202) 640-1161. It was more early morning site look when I surfing youtube, but I didn't give any information that was sensitive like SSID, or my credit card or debit card. Microsoft, ISPs, etc. " To do that they need to build up the roster of those seeking arbitration against Valve for the practice. We work entirely on a contingency so you will owe us nothing unless we recover money for you. Gamers with steam accounts could get money back. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Mason LLP Steam Lawsuit Legit: Unraveling the Facts and FAQs. Sep 1, 2023 Protected: Kia Hyundai Insurance Premium Litigation Aug 8, 2023 Real Page Antitrust Litigation Mar 22, 2023 Valve/Steam Game Overcharge. Define legit? It's as legit as lawyer's wanting to make a name for themselves. The Journey of Steam. Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. com Joined November 2021. Rowenta Steamer and Steam Iron Parts. who is 18 years or older, you may be eligible to bring an antitrust claim against Valve, the company that owns Steam. Judge John C. Overall, Mason LLP’s involvement in the STEAM lawsuit has been significant, and the firm’s lawyers have been working hard to achieve a favorable outcome for their clients. 518 Monroe Street. Phishing Scams. Steam having an illegal monopoly seems like a very iffy case you to me. The firm’s reputation as a reliable and experienced law firm has been instrumental in gaining the trust of the plaintiffs and the legal community. Master-Reason-6780 • 10 mo. a debt collection, a loan or equipment purchase), which comes in the form of a fake cheque or bank draft. 2. Lawyers. Steam settlement; who is eligible, how much you can. A. You need Mason LLP. Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. The lawsuit was filed in August 2018 and alleges that Valve has engaged in anti-competitive behavior in the digital video. watchportal. Let me know in DM your experiences with their bait and switches over the past years. Mason LLP. Join the Steam antitrust mass lawsuit and get refunded all your purchases. C. In-game purchases: A Steam refund is available on purchases made in games from parent company Valve for up to 48 hours after purchase, as long as the games hasn't been played, modified, or transferred. • 1 yr. More people = more buyers. The lawsuit covers residents of both. These class action lawsuits are nothing more than a charade to raise money for fruitless claims and provide tinpot law firms exposure and guaranteed work. :qr: Mason, LLP claims that people may be eligible to recover as much as 60% of the purchase price of all the games they’ve purchased on Steam over the last four years. turns easily and no steam is released from the [v]alve, then all pressure has been released. Gary Mason, a partner at Mason, LLP, confirmed to VERIFY in a phone interview in February that his firm and Zaiger were two firms offering to represent Steam customers in arbitration at that time. Let me know in DM your experiences with their bait and switches over the past years. Tutti i diritti riservati. Zywave Inc. 6K votes, 395 comments. Attorneys for Plaintiff, Geniva O’Keefe . Mason LLP. Mason LLP filed a Class Action Lawsuit against OakBend Medical Center (“OakBend”) on November 17, 2022. Same here, I was watching YouTube on my phone today and there was an ad on the home page that was clearly a scam, impersonating Mr Beast and claiming you get free money for visiting the website. " Moral of the story: Windfalls happen, but you should be able to verify them and not provide. Mason LLP’s Gary Mason has been appointed as Interim Co-Lead Counsel on JDC Healthcare Management LLC litigation. It’s a letter saying you are the beneficiary of a $13 million accidental death insurance policy from a relative of. 9 million unclaimed insurance policy from a. With a team of seasoned attorneys and a track record of successful cases, they have earned a reputation as one of the foremost law firms in the industry. csanders@masonllp. bouncingball8 legit & good Cassio? Reviews & complains?Illinois Steam users can submit a claim through the firm’s settlement website. Get to know your team by clicking View All. Get to know your team by clicking View All. These claims must be pursued in arbitration pursuant to the Steam Terms of Service. Discover a breathtakingly immersive world with stunning visuals and an intense combat system that will keep you. The court recently ruled that Steam customers could pursue their case again Valve in arbitration cases. To avoid being tricked with PayPal, try to convince the other user to send the goods first. Disney agreed to pay $9.